Honorable mention: Burt's Bees deep cleansing cream

Ok...so I left out this cleanser because it was in the shower and I forgot I even had it for a quick second.  This is my only favorite creamy thick cleanser. It feels so refreshing, and removes all makeup - but is especially great at removing eye makeup as far as cleansers go. Even though it is a creamy cleanser it does not clog pores and is great for all skin types, esp. combination skin. 
burtsbees.com